Thyroid Health for Women: What Your “Normal” Labs Might Be Missing

Dr. Kayla Borchers Collagen Benefits for Women's Health

hi, i'm dr. kayla!

DPT & mama of three who is passionate about proactive, root-case women’s health care.

JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST

You’re exhausted no matter how much you sleep. Your brain feels like it’s wrapped in cotton. You’re reaching for a sweater when everyone else is comfortable. And when you finally ask for bloodwork, you hear those three frustrating words: your labs are normal.

If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone, and you’re not imagining it.

On this episode of the Holistically Well Podcast, I sat down with Shelby Prenger, a nurse and host of the Be Well Health Simplified podcast, to zero in on one small gland with a very big job: the thyroid. Shelby works as a remote nurse with Modern Endocrine and is passionate about helping women advocate for themselves in healthcare. Together, we unpacked what the thyroid actually does, the signs it may be struggling, which labs to ask for, and how thyroid health shifts through every season of womanhood.

This post is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for individualized medical advice. Please talk with your healthcare provider before making changes to your labs, medications, or supplements.

What Does the Thyroid Actually Do?

 

Your thyroid is a small, butterfly-shaped gland at the front of your neck. Shelby describes it as the body’s thermostat. It helps regulate your energy, metabolism, and body temperature, which means it influences nearly every system in your body, from how your brain functions to how your hormones are produced.

When the thermostat is off, you feel it everywhere.

Common Signs Your Thyroid May Be Struggling

 

According to Shelby, the most common signs of an underactive thyroid include:

  • Fatigue that doesn’t improve with rest
  • Brain fog
  • Feeling cold all the time
  • Chronic constipation
  • Difficulty losing weight despite doing “all the right things”

Is It Your Thyroid, or Is It Postpartum?

 

Here’s where it gets tricky. Brain fog and constipation are incredibly common after having a baby. But I want to be really clear: common does not mean normal. These are symptoms we can address.

Before jumping straight to a thyroid rabbit hole, check the simplest boxes first:

  • Are you drinking enough water?
  • Are you pairing that water with electrolytes so it’s actually absorbed rather than just passing through?
  • Have you seen a pelvic floor physical therapist since giving birth?

That last one should be a yes for every single woman. During pregnancy, your baby took up space in the abdomen, pushing your diaphragm up and your bowels around. Postpartum, everything is finding its home again. Learning to relax the pelvic floor and abdominals, along with some manual therapy, can make a big difference for constipation.

If you’re in or near Sidney, Ohio, or want virtual support, you can book a 1:1 session with our team here.

Shelby adds an important layer: if you’ve checked all of those boxes and you’re still feeling exhausted, cold, foggy, or stuck with your weight nine, twelve, or eighteen months postpartum, that’s when it’s worth digging deeper into your thyroid. A stressful delivery, significant blood loss, breastfeeding demands, and micronutrient depletion can all take a toll on thyroid function.

Hypothyroidism vs. Hyperthyroidism vs. Hashimoto’s

 

These terms get thrown around a lot, so let’s break them down.

Hypothyroidism (Underactive Thyroid)

“Hypo” means low. Your thyroid isn’t producing enough active thyroid hormone, or your body isn’t using it effectively. This is where those fatigue, brain fog, cold, and constipation symptoms come in.

Hashimoto’s

Hashimoto’s is an autoimmune condition in which the body attacks the thyroid gland, leading to hypothyroidism. An important distinction: you can be hypothyroid without having Hashimoto’s.

Hyperthyroidism (Overactive Thyroid)

“Hyper” means high. Hyperthyroidism is often linked to Graves’ disease, an autoimmune condition in which antibodies overstimulate the thyroid. Symptoms are essentially the opposite of hypothyroidism: unintentional weight loss, heart palpitations, and anxiety. Like Hashimoto’s, Graves’ can show up after pregnancy or following stressful life events. You can also have an overactive thyroid without Graves’.

Why Your Labs Come Back “Normal” (And What to Ask For)

 

In conventional care, thyroid screening often starts and stops with TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone). If TSH is off, a free T4 may be added. But many women have a normal TSH and normal free T4 and still feel terrible.

Here’s why: your thyroid primarily produces T4, which then has to be converted into free T3, the active hormone your cells actually use. Free T3 is what drives so many of the symptoms women feel, and it often isn’t checked.

The Thyroid Labs to Ask About

 

When you talk with your provider, consider asking about:

  • TSH
  • Free T4
  • Free T3
  • Reverse T3
  • Thyroid antibodies (to screen for autoimmune involvement)

Optimal vs. “Normal” Ranges

 

Shelby explains that many lab reference ranges are based on the average of the local population, and most of us don’t want to be average. We want to feel well. Functional medicine providers tend to look at optimal ranges. For example, Shelby notes many women feel their best with a free T3 around 4, while conventional ranges may accept a level as low as 2 as “normal.”

Questions to Ask Your Provider

 

Any doctor can order a free T3, but hospital system protocols and insurance concerns can make it less routine. Shelby recommends coming to your appointment with a request, and asking questions like:

  • What labs are you willing to run for my thyroid?
  • What do you consider hypothyroid?
  • Would you treat me if my free T3 is low but my TSH and free T4 are normal?

If your provider isn’t open to that, a functional medicine or private practice provider may have more flexibility in how labs are ordered, interpreted, and treated.

Root Causes Behind Thyroid Dysfunction

 

Shelby calls thyroid dysfunction “the perfect storm.” Rather than one single cause, several stressors tend to stack on top of each other.

Stress Comes in Many Forms

 

Inflammation drives thyroid dysfunction, and stress drives inflammation. But stress isn’t just a hard day at work. Your body also experiences stress from:

  • Restrictive eating
  • Excessive exercise, especially when underfueled
  • Work and life demands
  • Grief
  • Even exciting things, like building a house

Your body doesn’t know the difference between running from a tiger and running for fun. So I want you to ask yourself: How do I feel after my workout? Ideally, you finish feeling like you still have energy to keep going (race day excluded!).

I’m a runner too. I’ve done a full marathon and more than ten half marathons. But in this season, nine months postpartum with my fourth baby and breastfeeding, two to three miles a few days a week is what leaves my body feeling energized. That doesn’t mean I’ll never run longer again. It means in this snapshot of time, that’s what my body can handle well.

Shelby agrees: exercise is wonderful, but it’s also a demand on the body. During an autoimmune flare, daily high-intensity workouts may not serve you. Consider limiting them to once or twice a week and filling the gaps with nervous-system-friendly movement like Pilates, walking, and gentle mobility.

Gut Health and Gluten

 

High cortisol from chronic stress can impact your gut microbiome and gut lining. Add highly processed gluten on top of an already stressed gut, and inflammation can climb. Shelby notes that many women with Hashimoto’s in particular feel much better on a gluten-free diet.

Dietary changes typically take three to four months to show their full benefit. After that, some women can reintroduce small amounts of gluten without symptoms. Shelby’s approach is to be “gluten mindful”: pay attention to how you feel, and let your diet be something you can realistically sustain, including family dinners.

Nutrient Deficiencies

 

Your thyroid needs raw materials to function. Common gaps Shelby sees include:

  • Iron and ferritin
  • Selenium (key for converting T4 into active T3)
  • Zinc
  • Vitamin D
  • Vitamin B12 and folate
  • Iodine

Because the conversion of T4 to T3 happens largely in the liver and gut, keeping inflammation low matters just as much as getting the right nutrients in.

Iron, Ferritin, and the Postpartum Thyroid

 

Iron deserves its own spotlight. Your thyroid needs iron to produce adequate thyroid hormone, and low iron is a major contributor to postpartum thyroid struggles.

Many women walk into pregnancy with low ferritin and never know it. Then they lose blood during delivery. Shelby shares that functional providers often consider a ferritin above 70 optimal, while conventional thresholds can be far lower.

Neither of us had our ferritin checked in earlier pregnancies. Mine was first tested with my most recent home birth, and it was lower than my midwives wanted. Beef liver alone barely moved the needle, so I needed a more targeted iron approach. Once my levels came up on a retest, I returned to beef liver for maintenance. That’s why individualized care matters so much.

A Food-First Approach

 

Shelby encourages prioritizing:

  • Animal proteins: red meat, fish, and chicken
  • Organ meats or organ capsules for highly absorbable iron and micronutrients
  • Healthy fats
  • Carbohydrates (yes, really, your body needs them!)

Beef liver is a fantastic proactive tool, but if your levels are already very depleted, you may need more targeted support from your provider first.

Thyroid Health Across Every Season of Womanhood

Preconception and Fertility

 

Shelby offers a helpful mindset shift: your thyroid hormones, cortisol, insulin, and sex hormones are all hormones, and hormones affect other hormones. If your thyroid isn’t functioning well, it’s likely impacting ovarian function and sex hormone balance downstream. That’s why addressing thyroid health before trying to conceive is so valuable.

Pregnancy

During pregnancy, T4 is especially important because it’s the hormone your baby relies on. Providers will closely monitor T4 if you’re hypothyroid. Approaches to T3 during pregnancy vary between providers, so this is an individualized risk-benefit conversation with your care team.

Your Cycle and Cortisol

When the thyroid is underactive, everything slows down, including your gut. Your gut helps clear used hormones, so constipation can cause estrogen to recirculate, contributing to estrogen-dominant symptoms. Elevated cortisol can also raise insulin, creating a cycle that affects your period.

Perimenopause

Perimenopause can begin quietly in your mid-thirties. Progesterone and testosterone typically decline first, and the body’s ability to convert T4 into T3 can slow with age, especially with inflammation. Many women entering perimenopause feel fatigued and foggy and discover their free T3 is low even when TSH and free T4 look normal. This is a great time to talk with your provider about thyroid support.

3 Steps to Take This Week If You Suspect Your Thyroid Is Off

 
  1. Reach out to your provider, or search locally for one who will run a full thyroid panel: TSH, free T4, free T3, and reverse T3.
  2. Decide what kind of support you want. Would you prefer a dietary and lifestyle approach, a physician-led approach that may include medication, or both?
  3. Find someone who supports that path, and remember there is more than one way to heal your thyroid. You have options.

The Takeaway

If Shelby could leave you with one message, it’s this: give yourself grace and nourish your body with whole, nutrient-dense foods. Don’t fear calories nearly as much as you fear a lack of nutrients.

And if you’ve been told your labs are normal but you still don’t feel like yourself, trust that instinct. Ask questions. Advocate for yourself. You deserve to feel well in every season.

Ready for individualized support? Book a 1:1 orthopedic or pelvic health PT session in Sidney, Ohio or virtually.

Connect With Shelby

 
  • Instagram: @bewellwithshelby_
  • Podcast: Be Well Health Simplified

This topic goes even deeper on the podcast. Whether you’re a listener, a reader, or a watcher — there’s a version of this conversation waiting for you. Tune in on Apple, Spotify, or YouTube, and if it resonates, a review helps more women find their way here.

Listen on Apple | Watch on Spotify | Watch on YouTube

you deserve to be supported

before, during and after pregnancy.

Looking to feel empowered and inspired along your perinatal journey? All things movement, nourishment and holistic lifestyle wellness – delivered to your inbox every Tuesday. Sent directly from an Orthopedic & Pelvic Health Doctor of Physical Therapy.